In today’s competitive work environment, financial incentives alone are insufficient to engage and retain top talent. Salary matters, but employees require meaning and personal growth in their careers. Strategic merit increases provide benefits beyond a simple pay rise. They can significantly impact employee engagement and loyalty when implemented effectively.
A merit increase is a pay raise based on performance. It can be used to motivate employees and increase their workplace engagement. This article examines ways to increase employee engagement through merit increases, deliver real value, and improve company performance.
What Is a Merit Increase?
Employees receive a merit increase based on their performance. Unlike general salary adjustments or cost of living raises, merit increases are based on an individual’s contributions.
A merit increase rewards an employee for their achievements and productivity and can be a powerful engagement tool. Their correct implementation indicated to employees their recognition and value, promoting a culture of appreciation and motivation. Companies must go beyond standard merit increases and explore innovative applications of this reward mechanism.
Merit Increases vs. General Raises
A merit raise rewards individual performance, while a general raise provides all employees with a uniform pay increase.
It’s essential for managers and HR professionals to understand the difference between a merit increase and a raise. General raises are aligned with inflation or industry standards, whereas merit raises reward high performance and supports the company’s strategic objectives.
Research has indicated that companies with merit-based pay systems tend to have higher employee engagement and retention. Such systems reward individual performance and achievements, helping employees feel recognized and valued for their contributions. Employees are more motivated and loyal when they feel their efforts impact their pay.
Merit Increases for Employee Involvement
Workers who experience appreciation and rewards are more likely to remain involved in their jobs. Often they are more driven, efficient, and in line with corporate objectives.
A disciplined merit increase program links employee performance directly to pay scale. This connection helps to promote the idea that diligence and effort pay off and produce an involved and committed workforce.
Businesses might top the usual salary increase. Tying merit increases to flexible benefits, mentoring programs, or tailored growth opportunities will help staff members feel appreciated. We will next look at how to do this.
1. Merit Raises and Employee Psychology
Using merit increases to raise employee motivation effectively depends on an awareness of the psychological effects of financial rewards. Merit raises can boost both inner and extrinsic drive, motivating staff members to reach higher productivity and involvement. Their motivating effect can be much influenced by the communication and framing of merit.
2. Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Motivation
Although many people consider financial incentives to be extrinsic motivators, merit increases can boost intrinsic motivation when employees see the money reward as a mirror of their successes and alignment with their goals.
Offering a merit raise as a recognition of growing leadership qualities could inspire a staff member hoping to be in charge. Businesses can improve this by tying merit increases to customized performance reviews that link financial incentives with individual career objectives.
3. Communicating the Merit Increase Effectively
Communication of a merit increase has a significant impact on how people perceive it. Research indicates that the transparency of the merit-based process greatly affects employee engagement. Employees are more motivated when they understand the criteria for merit-based raises and perceive them to be fair and representative of their contributions.
Open communication from managers, clear performance assessment guidelines, and honest feedback year-round are essential—not just during annual reviews. Managers must meet with employees post-merit increase to clarify the reasons behind it and how it relates to their future potential in the company.
Innovative Ways to Use Merit Increases to Drive Engagement
1. Tie Merit Increases with Learning and Development Programs
One creative way is to connect professional development possibilities with merit raises. Employees want chances for development, learning, and skill acquisition above only financial benefits.
Providing merit-based increases linked to involvement in learning and development initiatives shows that personal development is equally crucial as reaching KPIs.
Think about putting staff members in technical training, tuition reimbursement programs, leadership development, or management courses. Employees are more motivated to engage with programs when they understand that their raises depend on expanding their knowledge and career prospects.
Consider Engagedly’s Mentoring Complete program, which connects employees with seasoned mentors for professional advice. Employees meeting specific performance criteria and engaging in mentoring can earn merit increases that reflect their contributions and personal growth.
2. Incorporate Peer Recognition into Merit Raise Decisions
Integrating peer recognition into the merit increase process can enhance engagement. Managers might overlook the daily contributions of employees, but peers recognize them.
Create a structured peer recognition system for colleagues to nominate each other for merit raises based on performance, collaboration, or innovation. Valuing peer feedback fosters a culture of appreciation and trust.
Companies using Engagedly’s peer feedback system can track and recognize top performers through colleague reviews. This method identifies hidden talents and helps employees feel recognized by peers, fostering belonging.
3. Pair Merit Increases with Flexible Work Options
Flexibility is a highly desired benefit in today’s workplace. Merit increases offer financial rewards, but incorporating flexibility can enhance employee engagement.
Merit raises with options for flexible hours, remote work days, or compressed workweeks can enhance employees’ sense of value and control over their work-life balance. This is significant for employees who may not be mainly driven by financial rewards but still seek appreciation for their contributions.
4. Gamify the Merit Increase Process
To boost engagement, think about adding gamification to your merit-raising process. Gamification uses game elements like points, badges, and leaderboards to motivate employees to reach performance goals.
Employees could earn points for achieving specific goals or completing projects, with top performers receiving merit increases quarterly or annually. Making the process enjoyable and competitive can motivate employees to stay engaged and pursue their merit-based rewards.
Platforms like Engagedly support gamification and performance tracking, enabling companies to create engaging merit-based incentive structures that enhance employee performance.
5. Use Merit Raises to Encourage Cross-Department Collaboration
Merit increases can foster collaboration, a point often overlooked. Merit raises usually reflect individual performance, but could they be used to encourage teamwork across departments?
Using team-based metrics in your merit increase system can promote collaboration among employees across departments. Introduce team goals for employees to collaborate on a shared target, with merit increases based on overall performance.
This enhances collaboration and ensures employees work together towards company goals, boosting overall engagement.
Merit Increases as Part of a Broader Compensation Strategy
A successful compensation strategy involves more than just merit increases. Organizations should integrate merit-based pay into a comprehensive strategy that also includes benefits, perks, and career development to foster long-term employee engagement. A solid compensation strategy makes employees feel valued through both financial rewards and overall recognition of their contributions.
Follow these key steps to develop a comprehensive compensation strategy:
1. Balancing Merit Increases with Non-Financial Perks
Merit increases provide financial rewards, but non-financial perks like flexible schedules, learning programs, and wellness initiatives greatly enhance employee satisfaction. Companies can create packages that combine financial and non-financial rewards, providing a balanced approach to employee motivation.
Employees may receive a merit increase for outstanding performance and have chances to join exclusive leadership development programs. This dual reward system meets employees’ financial needs and supports their personal growth and career advancement.
2. Aligning Merit Increases with Organizational Culture
Organizations with clear cultures can use merit increases to reinforce important values and behaviors. Aligning merit with behaviors that reflect the company’s mission and values encourages employees to integrate those behaviors into their work ethic. A company that values innovation might link merit increases to employees who show creativity and contribute to breakthrough projects.
The Role of Continuous Feedback in Merit Increases
Implementing a continuous feedback loop is an effective way to link merit increases to employee engagement. Annual performance reviews may not offer the engagement required in today’s fast-paced work environments. Ongoing feedback sessions enable managers to discuss performance regularly, make necessary adjustments, and ensure employees stay on track for merit increases.
Benefits of Continuous Feedback for Employees
Continuous feedback offers several advantages for employees, such as:
Clear Expectations: Regular check-ins help employees understand expectations and adjust their work as needed.
Timely Recognition: Employees receive insights on their performance without waiting for the annual review. Real-time recognition of achievements enhances morale and engagement.
Growth Opportunities: Frequent feedback helps employees identify improvement areas and act before it affects their merit increase chances.
Benefits for Employers
Continuous feedback enables employers to track performance more accurately. Employers can base merit increases on a broader understanding of an employee’s performance over time, rather than relying on just one performance review. This reduces bias, enhances transparency, and assures employees that their merit raises are genuinely deserved.
The Role of Technology in Merit Increase Programs
Modern HR technologies are crucial for efficiently implementing and monitoring merit increases. Software tools like Engagedly can help companies set performance metrics, track employee achievements, and allocate merit raises transparently and based on data.
Engagedly’s platform helps companies simplify performance reviews and develop tailored merit-increase strategies that match individual goals with organizational objectives. The platform offers peer feedback, goal tracking, and mentoring, ensuring employees feel valued, supported, and motivated.
Technology can enhance the accuracy and fairness of your merit increase system while also creating a more engaging experience for employees.
Using Merit Increases to Retain Top Talent
Keeping top talent is essential for any organization. Merit increases effectively retain high performers by rewarding their contributions and providing financial incentives to remain. To keep top talent long-term, merit raises should be part of a broader strategy that includes career development and future opportunities.
1. Merit Increases and Career Paths
Linking merit increases to clearly defined career paths is an effective method for retaining top talent. Employees are more likely to remain committed to the company when they recognize that their performance affects their salary and career advancement.
High-performing employees may receive merit increases tied to promotions or new responsibilities, clarifying how their contributions are valued and how they can grow within the organization.
2. Avoiding the “Merit Ceiling” Effect
Merit increases can cause employees to feel like they’ve reached a ceiling, believing they’ve received all the financial rewards possible for their role. Companies should regularly evaluate their compensation strategy to provide ongoing opportunities for employees to earn rewards. Companies could include larger merit raises for exceptional achievements or bonuses for major project contributions.
Case Studies: Real-World Success with Merit Increases
Let’s take a look at a few real-world success stories to exemplify strategies for increasing employee engagement:
1. Altisource’s Career Development and Goal-Setting Success
In 2017, Altisource adopted Engagedly’s goal-setting and continuous performance management tools to improve tracking of employee objectives and career development. They wanted a simple system for straightforward employee adoption that aligned with wider organizational goals. Altisource utilized the platform to manage cascading goals and streamline the performance review process.
Key Results:
Altisource improved its goal-setting system, enhancing employee participation in performance reviews.
Improved career development pathways aligned employee goals with organizational strategy.
2. Actifio’s Performance Review Transformation
Actifio, a global data virtualization company, struggled with employee engagement in its annual review process, as only 45–50% of employees completed self-evaluations. After implementing Engagedly’s platform, Actifio completed 100% of reviews, significantly improving participation. This shift led to a nearly 100% increase in employee engagement, showcasing the effectiveness of Engagedly’s performance management system in enhancing employee morale and engagement.
Key Results:
The performance review completion rate rose from 45-50% to almost 100%.
The performance management process has significantly improved, as evidenced by the nearly 100% increase in employee engagement.
3. Nuspire Improves Employee Engagement by 15%
Nuspire, a managed security services provider, encountered issues with low employee morale and engagement in certain parts of the company. They collaborated with Engagedly to implement the E10 Engagement Survey, gaining insights into key drivers of employee engagement. They introduced several engagement programs over the year, including performance management enhancements and recognition modules.
Key Results:
Employee engagement rose by 15%.
Executed performance management strategies from survey insights, resulting in enhanced morale.
Wrapping Up
When strategically applied, merit increases effectively boost employee engagement. Companies can enhance workforce motivation and commitment by integrating career development, peer recognition, and collaboration alongside basic pay raises.
Engagedly helps organizations track performance and peer recognition, driving long-term engagement, satisfaction, and performance across the workforce. Organizations seeking to remain competitive and retain top talent can use merit increases as a way to enhance growth, motivation, and a culture of excellence beyond just financial compensation.
Integrating merit increases with platforms like Engagedly allows organizations to manage, track, and personalize rewards effectively, aligning individual and corporate goals for mutual success.
Discover how Engagedly can enhance your merit-based engagement strategies by exploring its solutions.
FAQs
1. What is a merit increase?
An employee receives a merit increase based on their performance and contributions, not on general salary adjustments for all employees.
2. What is the difference between a merit increase and a raise?
A general raise applies to all employees, usually to account for inflation or market standards, whereas a merit raise is based on individual performance and rewards specific achievements.
3. How do merit increases enhance employee engagement?
Merit increases employee engagement by linking performance directly to rewards. Employees who are aware of their valuable contributions and rewards tend to stay motivated and committed.
4. Can we combine merit increases with non-financial incentives?
Pairing merit increases with non-financial rewards like flexible work options or career development can boost employee satisfaction and engagement.
5. How can companies effectively manage merit increases?
Platforms like Engagedly help companies streamline merit increases, track performance metrics, and ensure fair and transparent raise allocations.
Srikant Chellappa is the Co-Founder and CEO at Engagedly and is a passionate entrepreneur and people leader. He is an author, producer/director of 6 feature films, a music album with his band Manchester Underground, and is the host of The People Strategy Leaders Podcast. He is currently working on his next book, Ikigai at the Workplace, which is slated for release in the fall of 2024.