The Cost of Fraud in HR and How to Stop It?

An ACFE report says that a corporate business loses an average of 5% of the annual turnover due to HR fraudulent activities. Human resources fraud is a real problem that is affecting global companies and their credibility, stability, and integrity.

What is fraud in HR? HR fraud covers various cases of fraud, such as document fabrication, payroll fraud, and employee benefits fraud. Its detrimental effects include the financial losses caused by such unlawful conduct, damage to businesses’ image, and decreased worker morale. In addition to monetary losses, all these activities may lead to lawsuits and a loss of trust among partners. Furthermore, the risk of non-adherance to regulations can result in a complete cessation of business activities or a compliance violation.

Businesses that try to be successful in combating HR fraud implement effective verification methods, educate the staff on ethical rules through training programs, and utilize advanced technologies like AI and data analytics to detect abnormalities quickly.

Also read: Expert Tips for Networking With Other HR Professionals

The High Cost of HR Fraud

Unlike theft or embezzlement, the monetary impact of HR fraud is not limited to direct losses alone. It includes both direct and indirect expenses that negatively affect the organization’s profitability. These real losses can be experienced in a short period and bring a significant level of burden to the company.

Probing fraudulent activities might require a lot of resources, including hiring forensic accountants and other legal experts, which raises expenditures even more. Prosecution of fraudsters, as well as the possibility of being sued, results in yet another extra cost.

However, the invisible cost of this kind of crime can be even more detrimental. A damaged reputation can kill customer loyalty and investor confidence, leading to reduced revenue and slumping market share. Furthermore, the consequences inside the company, like demotivated employee morale and trust, could have deep long-term impacts, too. Employees are likely to get disappointed, which will lower productivity, increase turnover, and create an unsupportive working environment.

Also read: Insights for HR: How to Support to HR Teams Through Downsizing Challenges

Common Types of HR Fraud

Payroll Fraud

  • Timesheet Manipulation: Employees may alter their timesheets to overstate hours worked, leading to inflated paychecks.
  • Fake Employees: Fraudsters may create fictitious employees in the payroll system and divert funds to themselves in the name of nonexistent individuals.

Expense Report Fraud

  • Inflated Expenses: Employees may exaggerate business-related expenses or submit false receipts to obtain reimbursement for personal expenses.
  • Personal Purchases: Fraudulent employees may use company funds for personal purchases and falsely claim them as business expenses.

Benefit Fraud

  • False Claims: Employees may submit fraudulent claims for benefits they are not entitled to, such as healthcare reimbursements or insurance claims.
  • Unauthorized Dependents: Individuals may fraudulently add ineligible dependents, such as non-family members, as nominees to their benefit plans to receive additional benefits.

Resume/Application Fraud

  • Fake Credentials: Job applicants may provide falsified educational qualifications, certifications, or professional licenses to secure employment.
  • Experience Falsification: Applicants may exaggerate or fabricate their work experience, job responsibilities, or achievements on their resumes or job applications.
Also read: Top 7 Productivity Hacks Used by Successful HR Leaders

How HR Can Prevent Fraud?

Explained below is the role of HR in fraud prevention.

Implement Strong Hiring Practices

  • Conduct Thorough Background Checks: Verify credentials, employment history, and criminal records to ensure the integrity of new hires.
  • Conduct Reference Checks: Contact previous employers or professional references to confirm candidates’ qualifications and suitability.

Develop Clear and Well-Communicated Policies

  • Define Acceptable Behavior: Establish explicit guidelines outlining prohibited actions and the consequences of engaging in fraudulent behavior.
  • Communicate Policies: Ensure all employees are aware of company policies regarding fraud prevention through regular training sessions, employee handbooks, and internal communications.

Establish a System of Segregation of Duties

  • Divide Responsibilities: Distribute tasks among multiple employees to prevent any single individual from having sole control over critical processes, such as payroll or expense approvals.
  • Implement Checks: Introduce checks and approval teams to verify transactions and ensure accountability at each stage of the HR process.

Regularly Review and Update HR Processes and Controls

  • Conduct Audits: Perform regular audits of HR processes and controls to identify vulnerabilities and areas for improvement.
  • Adapt to Changes: Stay informed about evolving fraud schemes and adjust policies and procedures accordingly to effectively address emerging threats.

Train Employees on Fraud Awareness

  • Educate Staff: Provide comprehensive training on recognizing red flags of fraud, such as unusual expense patterns or discrepancies in documentation.
  • Encourage Reporting: Establish confidential channels for employees to report suspected fraudulent activity and ensure they feel empowered to raise concerns without fear of retaliation.

Create a Culture of Ethics and Open Communication

  • Lead by Example: Demonstrate a commitment to ethical behavior from top management down, fostering a culture of integrity and honesty throughout the organization.
  • Encourage Transparency: Encourage open communication channels where employees feel comfortable discussing concerns and seeking guidance on ethical dilemmas.
Also read: Careers Spotlight: What Is an HR Generalist?

Additional Tips for Stopping HR Fraud

Utilize Technology for Monitoring and Data Analysis

  • Implement Fraud Detection Software: Utilize advanced software solutions that employ algorithms and machine learning to identify irregularities in HR data, such as payroll discrepancies or anomalous expense claims.
  • Utilize Data Analytics: Leverage data analytics tools to analyze patterns and trends, allowing for early detection of potential fraud indicators.

Conduct Internal Checks Regularly

  • Schedule Routine Audits: Conduct periodic audits of HR processes, including payroll, benefits administration, and expense management, to identify any discrepancies or fraudulent activities.
  • Rotate Auditors: Rotate audit teams periodically to ensure fresh perspectives and mitigate the risk of collusion or complacency.

Establish a Confidential Hotline for Reporting Suspected Fraud

  • Provide Anonymity: Establish a dedicated hotline or online reporting system where employees can report suspected fraudulent activities anonymously, encouraging whistleblowers to come forward without fear of retaliation.
  • Ensure Confidentiality: Guarantee confidentiality and protection for individuals reporting fraud, emphasizing the importance of maintaining their anonymity throughout the investigation process.

Partner with a Fraud Investigator for High-Risk Scenarios

  • Seek Expert Assistance: Engage the services of experienced fraud investigators or forensic accountants to conduct thorough investigations in cases of suspected fraud, particularly those involving complex schemes or high financial stakes.
  • Collaborate with Law Enforcement: When necessary, work closely with law enforcement agencies or regulatory bodies to investigate and prosecute individuals involved in serious fraud, ensuring swift and appropriate action is taken.
Also read: HR Development (HRD) vs HR Management (HRM) – Key differences

Summing Up

In conclusion, the cost of fraud in HR entails a great deal of expenses, including monetary losses, brand reputation damage, and lawful implications. Therefore, implementing stringent preventive structures and promoting a culture of trust and accountability will enable organizations to successfully tackle the risks of this fraud. Leveraging advanced technologies such as data analytics, biometrics, and AI-facilitated monitoring systems will help identify the signs of fraud and prevent them from happening. Moreover, wide-ranging comprehensive training programs for employees and periodic updating of policies and processes can enhance awareness and vigilance among employees.

360-degree Feedback

Frequently Asked Questions

  • How should businesses respond to suspected HR fraud?

Businesses should respond promptly to suspected HR fraud by conducting a thorough investigation, involving relevant stakeholders such as HR, legal, and finance departments, preserving evidence, and taking appropriate disciplinary action against perpetrators. They can also implement corrective measures to prevent future incidents and notify relevant authorities if necessary.

  • What are the warning signs of HR fraud?

Warning signs of HR fraud may include inconsistencies in employee records, sudden changes in spending patterns, unexplained discrepancies in financial reports, complaints from employees regarding pay or benefits, and reluctance to provide information or access to records.

  • How can businesses recover from the impact of HR fraud?

Businesses can recover from the impact of HR fraud by swiftly addressing the situation and implementing stronger controls and monitoring mechanisms. They can rebuild trust with employees and stakeholders through transparency and accountability and learn from the incident to strengthen their fraud prevention strategies in the future.

Subscribe To The Engagedly Newsletter